Pies ’n’ Thighs started in 2006, in the shadow of the Williamsburg Bridge. We took over a beer storage closet and transformed it into a tiny kitchen with six stools, serving huge donuts, two-napkin smoked pork sandwiches and salty, crispy fried chicken. The New York Times called the pies and the thighs “…a compelling combination, well executed and put forth with real heart—the sort of restaurant that’s hard to find, especially in the big city, but easy to love once found.”
We believe that comfort food speaks to everyone. We met as cooks at Diner, a nearby Brooklyn institution that has been the parent restaurant of many local favorites. We are inspired by classic American dishes, Mexican and Californian cuisine, and the Slow Food movement’s attention to ingredients.
We have been awarded Best Donut in New York by New York, Best Biscuits in New York by the New York Daily News, and Best Apple Pie and Best Fried Chicken in national surveys by Food & Wine and Bon Appétit.
Our pork and bacon comes from the Duroc and Berkshire breeds of pig, sourced largely from the Ozark Mountain Pork Cooperative in Osage County, Missouri. Their pigs roam free, and they are raised without antibiotics or hormone supplements.
All of our poultry is air-chilled Bell & Evans chicken. It is certified Humanely Raised and Handled, without antibiotics or hormone supplements. Air-chilling produces better flavor and texture because the natural juices, proteins and enzymes of the bird remain in the meat during cooking.
For burgers, brisket, and corned beef, we use Vintage Natural Beef, produced by a California-based cooperative of family-owned ranchers raising cattle on a blend of grass and grain for a pure beef flavor. The animals are Humanely Raised and Handled, without added hormones, on a 100% vegetarian diet that is tested for pesticides.
is a baker, lover of all things sweet and fried, know it all, and partner at Pies ‘N’ Thighs. She studied pastry and the art of eating everything in sight at the French Culinary Institute in 2004. She has baked at Magnolia Bakery, The Biltmore Room, Diner, Marlow & Sons, and Momofuku Milk Bar. Sarah lives in Chinatown with her husband and son.
is co-owner, chef, and chief problem solver/cornbread-eater at Pies ‘N’ Thighs. Originally from Boston, she discovered a deep affinity for barbecue, slow cooked beans, and all things fried – the seeds of her love for Southern food. She has cooked at Diner, Marlow & Sons, The Spotted Pig, and Roberta’s. Carolyn loves eating spicy Asian and Mexican food with her husband, Dan Ross-Leutwyler.